« Oooh! I'm famous! | Main | Rest in Peace, Dan »
May 10, 2005
Summer Plans
First, I'm sorry I've not been posting the past few days -- my computer died ("fan error") and I don't have it repaired yet; I'm borrowing a friend's computer to write this. Hopefully, I'll have it repaired today (if not, I am going to be one very angry woman). Second, this will be a lengthy post. It speaks to something in my life that I've never really discussed here before, so I'm dedicating a little space to it for those who are interested (hi Mom!).
OK. Over the past months the talk around the law school has, naturally, been all about summer plans -- what firms people were going to work at, what cities people were scattering to, etc. Whenever I was asked that question, I said simply that I was going to "travel". And, indeed, I am. But that's not the whole story.
For the last many years I have weighed the pros and cons of having genital reconstruction surgery ("GRS"). For most of that time, I've believed that the cons outweighed the pros. But, about 6 months ago, I realized that I really wanted it. I never felt that it was necessary that I have surgery to make me "complete"; I truly have only occasional discomfort with my body as it exists (of course, every time I have to use a public toilet or every time I meet someone that I think I might like to get close with with are two of those times). No, for me, the decision to have "the surgery" was mostly practical. (I just re-read that paragraph and realized that it sounds like I used my intellect to the exclusion of my emotions in this decision and that's not an entirely fair characterization. For a very long time, I've felt like I really wanted to have surgery, but I always let my intellect rule against it. I've now simply let my intellect get out of the way).
So what are the arguments against having surgery? First, and foremost, of course, is the fact that it is a highly invasive procedure, one not without risk of complication. The recovery period is 6-8 weeks, and even longer before you can fully exercise your new parts. Why put your body through such major trauma if you don't need to? Secondly, it is very expensive. I will spend over $20,000 to have this little alteration done - to convert me from an outie to an innie. Third, after you've done it, the maintenance is forever (far more maintenance than not having it done; I'll leave it to your imagination). Fourth, it seems to buy into the larger social construct of gender and that annoys me. An acquaintance of mine, Nancy Nangeroni who is profiled in the A&E documentary "Transgender Revolution" (in which, incidentally, I make a small speaking appearance) lives her life fully out and proud as a "non-op" transsexual. I admire her greatly for this. I, on the other hand, first by never discussing this, and then by having surgery, am merely completing the last technical, perhaps legal, perhaps medical (but I can argue against all of those) step to jump from one box to the other but am still staying inside the gender system that society has created. Fifth, most people will never know, one way or the other (unless, I do something silly like publish it on my blog) whether I've had surgery or not. I live my life as a woman. I identify as a woman. I believe that most people with whom I interact see me as a woman (and, if there are any of you out there that know me who see me differently, now is a good time to use the fact that I allow anonymous commenting on this blog to speak up and say so).
So, given all those reasons to NOT have surgery, what are the reasons FOR? There are several and these are not necessarily in order of significance. First, I want to do some more international travel. In our country you cannot be get your sex designator changed on your passport without a letter from a surgeon saying that you've had irreversible gender reassignment surgery. I could get a passport that simply has "male" on it, but I am loathe to do so. In some situations, I think that may even present the possibility of physical danger. Secondly, it does allow me to experience intimate relationships without discomfort about my body. Third, I will no longer have to fear that some person is going to challenge my right or freedom to use the ladies' room. Many people, and some laws, only recognize the right to use the restroom based upon your genital configuration. Fourth, if -- heaven forbid! -- something should happen to me and I got charged with a crime, I don't want to end up in a men's cell, even temporarily. Fifth, if something were to happen to me that would require serious medical intervention, I don't want a paramedic stopping treatment and leaving me to bleed to death, as they did with Tyra Hunter, when they cut open my pants and are surprised by what they find.
I guess that although I see myself as always being an activist, I feel the need to fit in also. This helps me to fit in. And, I'm very happy and very excited (and more than a little scared!).
OK, if you've suffered through this post this long, thank you. I leave in the morning (5/11) for a week in Florida with my girls (and attending Amanda's conversion ceremony!) and my folks and then to Denver for a couple of days with my sister, and then to Trinidad, CO where Dr. Marci Bowers will perform her magic. If you are interested in knowing the address and contact info for me in the hospital, you may write to me and I'll send it to you. I go into the hospital on 5/23, surgery is on 5/24 (prayers, well-wishes, and positive light and energy, and cards are welcome!), I anticipate being released on Memorial Day, 5/30. I will spend an extra couple of days in Trinidad recovering. Then, my middle kiddle will fly out to drive me home. I should be back in Ann Arbor by the 7th of June, or so. I anticipate blogging from the hospital.
07:14 AM in Transgender, Transgenderism, Transition Stories | Permalink
TrackBack
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83452cb6e69e200d83445327753ef
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Summer Plans:
Comments
Denise -- what a brave and candid post. Good luck with the surgery! We'll keep you in our prayers. (It will be easy to remember which day -- it's Matthew's b-day!)
Posted by: Shelley | May 10, 2005 10:11:29 AM
I have never met you but am a regular reader who always appreciates your honesty, patience, perseverence, thoughtfulness, and adventurous nature. Thank you for sharing this post with the world. I am sure there will be many best wishes sent your way, and I will do my part to send mine.
Posted by: sarah | May 10, 2005 10:43:07 AM
Wow. I'm surprised to see you posting about this -- even though I don't know why I should be, since you tend to be very open and honest about your life. I'm sad to hear that so many of the reasons for having the surgery involve violence. But I guess, for now, that's reality. I can definitely see how it would remove anxiety about personal relationships.
Best wishes for the surgery! I hope it goes smoothly and you're thrilled with the results.
Posted by: CM | May 10, 2005 10:43:15 AM
Denise - Best wishes for the surgery. Such a brave and scary thing, and kudos to you for sharing it with us.
Posted by: transmogriflaw | May 10, 2005 11:56:26 AM
For sharing your thoughts and life- thankyou.It is really brave of you.My prayers and best wishes are with you.Hope it turns out the way you want it to be.<>
Posted by: Sunrayz | May 10, 2005 12:07:28 PM
Best wishes!!!!
Posted by: RSLS | May 10, 2005 1:51:28 PM
Denise,
Best wishes regarding your surgery and recovery time. You mentioned thoughtful arguments on both sides of the decision (this clues me in to how well your mind "thinks like a lawyer" in the sense of looking at both sides in a complex way and analyzing, etc. --> compliment). Either way, I view you as a woman because you ARE a woman. You have weighed the pros and cons for a long time and come to what is the right personal decision for you. I support you and will view you no differently.
Posted by: | May 10, 2005 2:23:35 PM
please send me your address. :-) (I have postcards and a surprise [a good surprise] to send.) :-)
Posted by: Katherine | May 10, 2005 4:29:51 PM
How do I see you? As an attractive person; intelligent, compassionate, fun, insightful, interesting, and more than a little courageous. I don't see you as male in any sense, and have no idea how I would react in an intimate setting to someone I perceive as female but who has "male parts," so I can't be a useful source of information there. I do know that I enjoy you.
As far as the rest - #(*%&#$ gender. I really don't care. And I support your decision wholeheartedly because you've obviously given it a huge amount of thought and because you are adult enough to know your own best interests.
Safe travels - of all sorts!
Posted by: Dawn Wolfe Gutterman | May 10, 2005 6:29:32 PM
Good luck in the hospital, Denise. Hope you enjoy your break too. My mom's actually having surgery that day too, but, uh, not for the same thing :)
Posted by: stag | May 10, 2005 6:30:55 PM
All my good energy vibes and fast-healing mojo are headed your way.
Posted by: Janine | May 10, 2005 10:49:10 PM
Denise,
When I read your reasons for both not wanting and wanting the surgery, I felt like I was ready about me!
I, too, waited for some time, in my case almost ten years before either top or bottom surgery. Marriage and a desire to travel were the top two reasons for my decision to have the surgeries.
Are you now aware that you can deduct your surgery on your taxes? Apparently the IRS changed its policy last year. Let me know if you want more info.
Take care,
Jay
Posted by: Jay Sennett | May 11, 2005 10:01:35 AM
You are an amazing women, no matter if you are an "innie" or an "outie". No one else can dictate your gender identity, but since the law can define your gender, the whole thing does become complicated. I admire your courage for all that you have been through -- physically, emotionally, socially, legally, psychologically, etc. -- to arrive at the woman you have become. I think identity is a lifelong process, and I wish you every best wish for your next step along this journey.
Posted by: Kristine | May 11, 2005 12:08:05 PM
Wow! This is news to me! When did you decide?!
J/K. Sorry I won't be going to Trinidad with you, but you'd better stop by the house on your way back. I'm looking forward to seeing you and Melody :D
Posted by: Michelle | May 11, 2005 12:28:40 PM
Denise,
Good luck with the surgery. I hope all goes well. Where will go to get this surgery? I thought it was hard to have this procedure done in the US. For the record, I have seen you around the law school and until I read your blog I had no idea you once lived as a man.
Posted by: lazlo | May 12, 2005 12:47:49 PM
Best of luck to you, Denise, and welcome to the world of innies. To the day when we are all seen as merely the people that we are, without all the crap about what stereotypical role we fit into. Namaste.
Posted by: donna Woodka | May 12, 2005 1:16:15 PM
sweetie,
as much as I am a non-conformist, it's your right to be absolutely happy with who you are. screw stereotypes, I wish you all the best.
because of the impossibility of sending you a card from over here that could reach you on time, look out for notes in your inbox :)
you're an amazing woman!
Posted by: particular ordinary. | May 13, 2005 1:50:42 AM